Why Role Play Isn’t Optional: The Case for Practice-Based Learning in Child Advocacy
September 1, 2026
by Dr. Kate Watson
The Advocacy Academy
Spotlight on The Advocacy Academy: A dedicated place for advocate growth and development
Experienced trainers know how much participants can resist role play. It can feel awkward, artificial, or intimidating. Still, practice is essential. No one learns to play the piano simply by listening to someone describe how it is done. At some point, fingers must touch the keys.
Clients do not experience an advocate’s theoretical understanding of trauma-informed care, implicit bias, or ethical standards. They experience the advocate’s behavior. They need an advocate who can respond when a client is ambivalent about making decisions, remain grounded when someone shares alarming information, ask effective questions under pressure, and manage the impulse to fix or take control.
These are performance-based skills, and performance-based skills require practice.
Why Information Alone Does Not Stick
Many professional skills cannot be fully developed through reading, watching, or listening alone. The science of learning consistently shows that people retain and apply information more effectively when they actively practice, retrieve knowledge from memory, make decisions, receive feedback, and adjust their approach. Practice strengthens neural pathways, builds automaticity, and transforms knowledge from something a learner can recognize into something the learner can use. This is especially important for complex human-service skills. Advocates need more than information. They need the ability to respond in real time, tolerate discomfort, adapt to the person in front of them, and continue improving through reflection and feedback.
The goal is to help advocates move from: “I understand what I should do” to “I have already practiced doing it.” That shift is huge.
Discomfort Is Part of Learning
Role play is sometimes avoided because it feels uncomfortable. That discomfort is not necessarily a flaw. It can be an important part of the learning process. Role play provides an opportunity to experience some of that discomfort in a controlled environment, where mistakes can become material for learning rather than causing harm to a client. The purpose is not to eliminate discomfort. It is to help advocates remain thoughtful, grounded, and responsive while discomfort is present.
The Limitations of Traditional Role Play
Traditional role plays often ask participants to alternate between playing the advocate and playing the client. This approach can provide a useful introduction to a skill, but it also has significant limitations.
First, the participant portraying the client may not respond realistically. That person may unconsciously make the conversation easier, provide information too readily, or behave according to assumptions about how a client “should” act. Real clients may hesitate, change the subject, minimize danger, express conflicting feelings, become frustrated, or decline the options being offered.
Traditional role play can also reinforce unhelpful habits if feedback is limited or inconsistent. Participants may repeat leading questions, rush into problem-solving, overlook signs of ambivalence, or rely on scripted responses without recognizing the effect those choices have on the interaction.
These limitations do not make traditional role play useless. They show why it should be designed carefully and supplemented with more realistic, supported forms of practice.
The Safety of a Trusted Consultation Group
A consultation group can provide an especially valuable setting for practice when its members have built trust over time. Psychological safety allows participants to take interpersonal risks, acknowledge uncertainty, try unfamiliar approaches, and make mistakes without fearing ridicule or harsh judgment. Members become familiar with one another’s strengths, habits, and growth areas. Feedback can therefore become more specific and meaningful over time.
Consultation groups also help normalize vulnerability. Mistakes become opportunities for collective learning rather than evidence of incompetence. In fact, repeated practice within a trusted group can create a productive cycle: practice leads to feedback, feedback informs reflection, reflection shapes the next attempt, and each attempt strengthens both skill and confidence. The group becomes a place where advocates can prepare for difficult conversations before facing similar situations with clients.
Finding Resources for Your Team of Advocates
To explore live workshops, skill labs, and consultation groups offered by The Advocacy Academy, visit www.AdvocacyAcademy.org or email . A representative can help identify the training and skill-development options that best meet the needs of individual advocates and their teams.
__________________________________________________________
Dr. Kate Watson is the President and Founder of The Advocacy Academy, which is a consulting company focused on the development of skilled victim and family advocates to reduce violence around the world. Through her work with The Advocacy Academy, she has conducted educational workshops in 32 states, 8 countries, and across many fields: healthcare, education, social services, financial advising, victim advocacy, corrections, and leadership. On average, Dr. Watson speaks to 10,000 live audience members each year. She is an on-going consultant to the Department of Defense, the NFL, and to major television networks. In addition to her speaking and consulting work, Dr. Watson sits on the Board of Directors for The Lady Parts Collective, which is a Los Angeles-based theater company specializing in the development of work relevant to women in the United States. She is also a Director Emeritus for the Motivational Interviewing Network of Trainers.
Dr. Watson is the author of three books: (1) Only Trying to Help: Higher Standards for Well-Meaning Friends, Colleagues, Parents, and Partners, (2) Motivational Interviewing for Victim Advocates, and (3) The Embodied Advocate: The Inner Work Necessary to be an Advocate Against Power-Based Violence.
